|
Thank you to John Hadden who wrote.
Edinburgh Crescents
"Do you think the location is definite?
(Perhaps not.- Peter Stubbs)
The background shows that the park area is
bounded by a low wall with several courses of stones.
Assuming that things haven't changed radically
since 1927, I think that many crescents in Edinburgh had either no raised
boundary or only a single block high, including Atholl Crescent and Coates
Crescents.
Also, the photo shows a gate to this park
area, whereas the grass areas at Atholl Crescent and Coates Crescents are
not enclosed (at least not now).
Claremont Crescent
I think a more likely candidate may be
Claremont Crescent. This has a low wall and a similar gate.
Also, the building style is very similar to that in the photograph.
There is more than one gate into the grass
area at Claremont Crescent, but the pattern of blocks on the building
stonework and the blemishes on the stones around the windows would suggest
that the building in the rear of this photo may be 18 or 19 Claremont
Crescent.
So could this photo have been taken there?
(Google Street View was most useful in
assisting me with this)"
John Hadden, Edinburgh: August 7, 2009 |